The last two installments of How to Talk so Kids will Listen covered Helping Kids Deal With Their Feelings and How to Engage Cooperation. Both are in the realm of the preemptive.
But what happens when you’ve tried all that and your kid still grabs a handful of dirt from the house plant, throws some of it in his sister’s painting while making sure to leave just enough to feed to the baby (don’t worry, turns out a bit of dirt is good for them)? Engage the magnetic force field to keep them away from the plant? (“Alexa, engage magnetic forcefield.”) Take away dessert forever? Revoke all current and future Disney privileges? Rage eating at a level typically reserved for professional competitions?
Faber and Mazlish land firmly on the side of no to all of the above and firmly no on punishment, opting instead for some concrete alternatives (no, not that concrete) below.
But before we get there, I found their definition of discipline supremely helpful: Discipline means education. Discipline is programmed guidance that helps develop internal self-control, self-direction, and efficiency.
The authors point out that study after study shows that punishment is counterproductive; it teaches kids that violence and aggression are acceptable. Instead of feeling sorry for what he’s done, making amends, and realizing how to do better later, the child is in pain and marinates in revenge fantasies (and not the good -- some dare say sexy -- Liam Neeson kind). Punishment deprives him of the opportunity to learn from his misbehavior.
While the authors are against punishment, they are pro-consequence. What’s the difference, you ask? Punishment is deliberately depriving a child or inflicting pain. Consequences are a natural result of the child’s behavior. Actions have consequences. The consequence of writing on the wall in crayon is having to clean it up and a break from crayons for a while. The consequence of choosing the movie Boss Baby is having to sit through the movie Boss Baby.
Rather than Punishment Try One or More of These Strategies:
Faber and Mazlish also highlight their structure for resolving challenging conflicts (same tactics used in international peace treaties and marriage counseling. Hey, if it’s good enough for The Hague, it’s good enough for me):
I loved this quote from the book:
“We have to stop thinking of the child as a problem that needs correction. We have to give up the idea that because we’re adults, we always have the right answer. We have to stop worrying that if we’re not tough enough, the child will take advantage of us…There is an important message built into this approach, it says, when there is conflict between us, we no longer have to mobilize our forces against each other and worry about who will emerge victorious and who will go down in defeat. Instead we can put our energy into searching for the kinds of solutions that respect both our needs as individuals.”
Go ahead and re-read this ^ and replace “child” with “partner,” “co-worker,” “person.” 😊. I’m putting it on a throw pillow – who’s in for the Kickstarter?
Admin Deets:
No news letter next week - I'm headed out on a computer-free vacation.
Were you forwarded this email and want to get in on the action? Sign-up here.
Are there parenting books/articles/podcasts you'd like me to review? Send them on over to ash@happyvolcanoes.com.
Pint-sized wisdom for your pint-sized people. Sourced from experts. Delivered to your inbox.
First some laughs. If any social media algorithm knows you are the parent of a young child, you have likely come across the advice videos by the very celebrated, smart child psychologist Dr. Becky Kennedy. She wrote a bestseller called “Good Inside” that was recommended to me by several Very Together mom friends and she currently has an Instagram following of 379 billion. We defer to her expertise between one and thirty times a day. Here is how [the insanely funny Bess Kalb] imagines she...
I didn't expect to find some lovely parenting wisdom from a Tim Ferriss Podcast with the CEO of a venison company, alas, here we are. His wife and him use two thought experiments/mental image/tools with parenting: When their kids are pushing their buttons and their fuse is short, they envision what it would be like to be 80 years old and have the ability to be transported back in time to this moment. They picture parenting as a tug of war with their kids that they eventually have to loose....
This week, an unlikely book: “The Inner Game of Tennis.” I’m not a tennis player, yet this book hits my top five. I also just heard that Michael Lewis credits this book for bringing fun into his life, so, there’s that endorsement. I recently re-read it with an eye toward parenting. I think it has a lot to teach us about how kids learn and how to cultivate and protect their curiosity. And it may help us rediscover that curiosity within ourselves. Unlike many Happy Volcanoes favorites, this...